Location:

Be vigilant against the infringement of users’ rights by certain intelligent terminals.

Recently, the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology issued a notice regarding 20 intelligent terminal products that violated users’ rights and interests. These products include smart speakers, smart locks, and learning terminals, among others, belonging to the category of intelligent hardware.
Previously, the relevant departments mainly issued public notifications regarding the violations of applications (APPs). This time, the scope has been expanded to carry out special handling for entire smart terminal products. Some analyses suggest that this highlights the necessity of strengthening personal information protection and establishing a security defense line during the development of smart terminals. Building a solid security defense line for smart terminals is not only the foundation for the steady and far-reaching development in the digital era, but also the requirement for safeguarding individual rights, promoting the healthy development of industries, and defending national information security.

The picture shows the intelligent terminal notification regarding behaviors that infringe upon user rights. It was taken from the website of the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology.
The issue of personal information security deserves attention.
Forcing users to grant access, collecting information beyond the scope, and sharing personal information privately… These behaviors of illegally collecting and using personal information are typical manifestations of individual intelligent terminals or applications infringing upon users’ rights and interests.
Taking the recent relevant notification from the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology as an example, the problems exposed by these 20 products are highly similar. Their commonalities can be summarized in three aspects: no provision of personal information handling rules, excessive collection of unnecessary personal information, and illegal transmission of personal information to the cloud.
In the “Black Cat Complaints” and on social platforms, the journalists also saw similar complaints from users: Some smartphone and smart speaker brands used users’ conversation content for targeted advertising push notifications. Another user reported that their smart TV collected excessive viewing habits and internet records, and even secretly recorded audio. And yet another user was concerned that the registered facial information was uploaded to the cloud by the smart lock manufacturer for processing and verification, creating a potential risk of being stolen by hackers.
Li Junhui, the director of the Social Governance Development Research Department of the China Judicial Big Data Research Institute, stated that some intelligent terminals have issues that infringe upon users’ rights and interests. The most prominent manifestation is that the processing of personal information does not strictly follow the “legal, proper, necessary and honest” principles stipulated in the Personal Information Protection Law. In practice, many users find it difficult to make their own judgments on which specific information various devices collect and the potential risks involved in such collection.
Infringing upon the collection and use of personal information is just one part of the security issues related to smart terminals. With the support of large models and intelligent agent technologies, the intelligence level of smart speakers and cameras has significantly improved. Moreover, due to their deep integration into daily life, the hidden security risks are even more complex.
This year, the country has launched the “Artificial Intelligence +” initiative, proposing to vigorously develop new-generation intelligent terminals such as artificial intelligence mobile phones and computers, as well as smart wearables. Against this backdrop, it is particularly important to build a solid foundation for the security of intelligent terminals.
“Intelligent terminals in fields such as government affairs and communication have acquired the attributes of critical infrastructure. Their security attributes have transcended the levels of individuals and industries, rising to the strategic level of national security.” In the opinion of Sun Mingjun, a member of the Expert Advisory Committee of the China Internet Association and the director of the Zhongguancun Intelligent Application Artificial Intelligence Research Institute, the intelligent terminal industry is an important component of the digital economy. Security is not a cost for development, but the core of competitiveness.

Viewers at the exhibition site got to know about the AI smart glasses. (Photo by Liang Xu, Xinhua News Agency)
Where does the root cause of the safety issue lie?
Regarding the compliance management of intelligent terminals, at the legal, standard and regulatory levels, China has generally established a governance framework characterized by “having laws to abide by, having standards to follow, and having supervision as a guarantee”.
Zha Chengzhan, a partner and lawyer at Beijing Jiawei Law Firm, said: “From a legal perspective, the Personal Information Protection Law and the Cybersecurity Law have established the basic rules for handling personal information, requiring that the processing of personal information must have clear and reasonable purposes and obtain the consent of the individual. In addition, departmental regulations such as the ‘Regulations on the Protection of Personal Information of Telecommunication and Internet Users’ provide detailed guidelines for specific requirements.”
Zhao Chengzhan stated that at the policy implementation level, relevant ministries and commissions have jointly carried out special campaigns for personal information protection for several consecutive years, which has become a regular regulatory mechanism. For instance, the 2025 special campaign announcement clearly designated issues related to the unauthorized collection and use of personal information in apps, SDKs, smart terminals, and offline consumption scenarios as the key areas for governance. The regular “APP (SDK) Notification on Infringing upon User Rights” released by the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology is precisely the specific implementation of these laws, regulations, and policies.
Since a complete management system has been established at the institutional level, why are there still some intelligent terminals and applications that engage in actions that infringe upon users’ rights and interests?
In the opinion of Qu Yunxuan, the head of Qian’an Pan Guo Laboratory, the development of terminal devices is vigorous, and some products have repeatedly infringed upon users’ rights and interests. There are several imbalances behind this:
Firstly, there is an imbalance between technological investment and safety awareness. Some manufacturers focus too much on functionality while neglecting safety during product development. They fail to incorporate privacy protection concepts into the product design stage, resulting in the need to “patch up” later on, which merely addresses the symptoms rather than the root cause.
Secondly, there is an imbalance between commercial benefits and user rights. In the fierce market competition, “data monetization” has become an irresistible profit driver for some enterprises. Excessive collection of user information for purposes such as precise advertising delivery and user profiling analysis has led to gray business models, resulting in frequent occurrences of excessive data requests and silent data uploads in the background.
The third issue is the imbalance between regulatory requirements and their implementation. Although laws and regulations such as the Cybersecurity Law and the Personal Information Protection Law have established a basic framework, in the innovative and dynamic field of smart hardware, there are still difficulties in the effective implementation of some provisions in specific scenarios and in achieving thorough supervision.
Cao Zhiyong, a researcher from the Artificial Intelligence Research and Evaluation Department of the China Software Testing Center, also believes that this is the result of the combined effect of multiple factors driven by commercial interests. However, at its core, it is the “prioritization of interests” mindset of some manufacturers that overrides the protection of user rights in specific scenarios.
It is understood that for enterprises that violate regulations, various post-event handling measures have been established, including notification,责令 rectification, removal of applications, fines, and even referral to judicial authorities.
Li Junhui suggested, “For equipment or manufacturers with prominent problems, the People’s Procuratorate, the consumer organizations stipulated by law, and the organizations determined by the national cyberspace administration department can promptly file a public interest lawsuit to promote the formation of benchmarks or typical cases, and to clearly define the ‘bottom line’ and ‘red line’ for personal information protection or the healthy development of the industry.”

Last Articles

MILESTONES

Still hungry? Here’s more

From our beginning to where we are today, each milestone represents our commitment to innovation and industrial excellence.

FIND ARTICLES & GUIDES

VT Gear Logo

Submit Your Request

Fill out the form with your specific requirements in 1 minute.

Instant Routing

Your inquiry will be automatically routed to our dedicated sales team.

Fast Response

We will contact you via email within 3 business hours with solutions.

Start Your Inquiry

Please provide your specifications below. We will review your request immediately.